Finding the Best Chocolate:

How to Recognize Quality at a Glance

January 2025

by Sophie Fischer

“Life is like a box of chocolates. You never know what you're gonna get,” is a famous line from Forrest Gump. But what if you knew exactly what to look for?

Whether you’re a chocolate lover or an expert, we’ll show you how to identify high-quality chocolate before you even take a bite. From flavours and texture to cacao content and bean origin, discover the secrets of truly premium chocolate.

Sensory Characteristics – Enjoying Chocolate with All Your Senses

Flavour
High-quality chocolate offers a wide range of flavours, presenting a sensory journey. Exceptional chocolate can feature notes of ripe berries, roasted nuts, freshly brewed coffee, or even delicate floral hints. A taste that is simply “sweet” often indicates inferior chocolate overloaded with sugar. The secret to fine chocolate? Look for a harmonious balance of flavours that meld together – much like a well-composed symphony where each note is perfectly tuned.

Texture
Premium chocolate melts evenly and smoothly on your tongue, creating a luxurious sensation similar to velvet gliding through your fingers. This creamy texture results from meticulous processing techniques. Industrial chocolate, processed to an ultra-fine particle size below 20 microns, is typically smooth but lacks in flavour and depth due to poor quality of beans, processing and added flavours. In contrast, craft chocolate—where grinding and conching are often combined—may have a slightly crumblier texture due to its artisanal processing. Those are characteristic of high-quality craft chocolate, reflecting a careful balance of flavours and textures rather than an indicator of lesser quality.


Ingredients – Less Is More

Cacao Content
The cacao content is a crucial indicator of both flavour and quality. High-quality chocolate typically contains a higher cacao percentage – usually 70% or more. This high percentage leads to a more intense and complex flavour experience, with more cacao mass and less sugar. It allows the natural aroma of the cacao bean to shine through.

However, more isn’t always better. The key is achieving the right balance to highlight a diverse range of flavours. Dark chocolates with high cacao content deliver a rich, intense experience, while milk chocolates, with cacao percentages between 30% and 50%, offer a milder, sweeter taste. The balance between cacao butter and sugar plays a significant role in the final flavour profile. In milk chocolate, the quality of the milk powder is also crucial in shaping the taste experience.

Additives
The brevity of an ingredient list attests to quality. Good chocolate should only contain a few ingredients: cacao mass, cacao butter, sugar and milk powder (of course) if it's a milk chocolate. So not (artificial) additives, emulsifiers like lecithin, or vanilla. Adding extra cacao butter is mostly needed with a cacao content of less than 80% to get a better melt and fluency. Many craft makers avoid adding additional cacao butter, even in 70% dark bars, allowing for a more intense flavour experience. Extra butter can soften the flavours, so minimal ingredients preserve the chocolate’s pure aroma and taste. Look for products with simple ingredient lists to ensure you’re getting a truly premium product. 

Origin – Transparency and Quality

The cacao bean is the heart of chocolate. Much like fine wine, the essence of chocolate depends greatly on the bean’s origin. South American cacao, where the plant originated, often offers a greater complexity of flavours. While African cacao is widely used in large-scale production with robust, high-yield varieties, it also includes some exceptional beans with unique flavours, like Udzungwa. Since most African cacao focuses on robust varieties for industrial production, flavors can be milder. When choosing chocolate, look for transparency in bean origin and certifications that indicate ethical production practices.

Processing – The Art of Chocolate Making

Exceptional chocolate is crafted not only from the finest ingredients but also through precise processing.

Fermentation and Drying
After harvest, cacao beans are first fermented, usually for about 5–7 days. This process reduces bitterness and develops initial flavours. The beans are then dried, often still in the country of origin, before being exported. Fermentation and drying form the basis of the bean's flavour profile.

Roasting
Roasting typically occurs once the beans reach chocolate production facilities, such as in Europe or the United States. Roasting further develops and intensifies the flavours – a process similar to coffee roasting. The roasting duration and intensity play a critical role in shaping the flavour profile, refining the aromas developed in fermentation.

Conching
Conching is akin to applying the final brushstrokes on an artist’s masterpiece. It involves slowly stirring the chocolate mass to refine its texture and flavour. This process ensures that all aromas blend harmoniously and the texture becomes luxuriously smooth. The quality of conching determines whether the chocolate melts gracefully on your tongue – much like a masterwork achieving its final brilliance through expert artistry.


Tempering
The perfect structure and shine of chocolate come from tempering. This process involves heating and cooling the chocolate to specific temperatures, allowing the cacao butter crystals to form properly. Proper tempering gives the chocolate a crisp texture and a glossy sheen – similar to how a diamond reveals its full splendour through meticulous polishing.

Each Step Matters
From the genetic variety of the beans and environmental conditions to seasonal influences, fermentation, and drying – every stage of chocolate processing impacts the final quality. Each step is essential, and only the careful integration of all factors leads to a truly unique and refined flavour experience.


Consistent Quality – Chocolate That Does Good

Sustainable and fair production conditions are not only ethical but also impact the quality of chocolate. Fair labor practices and environmentally conscious cultivation help ensure that beans are carefully harvested and processed. However, not all sustainable and fair chocolate is made with high quality beans and poor handling of beans can also lead to lower quality. At Original Beans, we set high standards, respecting both cacao genetic cultivation and the environment. From direct trade partnerships to 95% biodegradable and compostable packaging, our commitment results in a pure, unadulterated taste that defines mindful enjoyment.

Conclusion – The Best Chocolate at a Glance
Good chocolate is more than just a sweet treat – it’s an experience that enriches the senses. When choosing your next chocolate, consider sensory characteristics, ingredients, and origin to find quality that shines from bean to bar.

Craving a piece of chocolate? Explore the range of premium chocolates at Original Beans – where true quality is instantly recognisable!

By Sophie Fischer

January 2025

Silky notes of caramel, hazelnut and salt float through this chocolate from rare Arriba cacao like a cloud forest’s mist where tree frogs bask.


The daily mists and rains rising up from the Pacific to the Esmeraldas cacao forests cannot unsettle a sloth whose thickish fur grows upwards for the perfect water run-off. Your purchase of Esmeraldas 42% helps protect Ecuador’s last cloud forest and the sloth’s gentle way of life.


  • Pure Taste

  • Climate +

  • Fair +

  • Compostable

What´s happening

More Stories